If you asked John Anthrop to describe his sister Mary Ellen, he would tell you she was “definitely a historian, very calm, very organized, clever, cheerful, thoughtful and smart, and an antique collector.” Anyone who had her as a teacher would agree. So would anyone who attended one of her Heritage Days, met her at the Tippecanoe County Public Library book sale, or stopped by her classroom. To generations of students she was simply Miss Anthrop, and she embodied the best of a St. Lawrence Rambler and a Central Catholic Knight.
A Home of Faith and Family
Mary as a young student. She attended St. Lawrence Elementary and graduated from Central Catholic in 1968.Mary attended St. Lawrence Elementary School and graduated from Central Catholic in 1968. She earned a BS in History Education at Purdue University and completed a Master’s degree in History in 1975. In 1976 she came home to Central Catholic and began a 40-year career as an educator and National History Day mentor.
When asked why she stayed so long, her answer was simple: “Central Catholic was my home. There I found a home of faith and family.”
Telling the Stories of Those Who Came Before
Mary’s passion for the past was contagious. John graduated before she began teaching, but all four of his sons were in her classes: Jade, Dru, Danny and Jackson. They remember how passionately she taught. She often focused on the local history of minorities, women and ordinary people, and she told her students why that mattered:
“If you don’t record a people’s history, it’s as if they did not exist. That is morally wrong. You are ignoring their existence and letting them pass unremembered.”
She regularly stayed for hours after school to help students with homework, History Day projects, or whatever else they needed. Mary never married, and her students were like her children. She wanted every one of them to succeed.
Education First
Mary was diagnosed with cancer in the summer of 2024 and passed away on November 9 of that year. As she prepared for the end of her life, her thoughts turned to the future students of the Lafayette Catholic School System.
She loved antiques, toys and especially chocolate, but she lived a quiet, frugal life. As she and John reviewed her finances, Mary insisted that $100,000 of her savings go to Central Catholic for school building improvements. She pointed at John and added, “Not athletics.” Mary was a sports fan and supported athletics, but for her, education always came first.
Her Gift at Work
After meeting with John and Jana Anthrop, LCSS put Mary’s investment to work:
- $20,000 gave her long-time classroom new flooring and furniture.
- $60,000 paid for repainting the 100 and 200 halls and updating the women’s restrooms.
Her generosity has also inspired anonymous alumni to continue what she started. Plans are underway to replace the school’s original 1957 lighting, a project of about $180,000.
“Thank You, Miss Anthrop”
Mary had a habit of remembering who was responsible for each change to Central Catholic’s building and culture. Whenever something struck her as funny, annoying or important, she would mutter, “Thank you, Fr./Sr./Mr./Mrs. (insert name) for making that ‘Important Change.’”
So the next time you walk down those brightly repainted hallways or stop by her old classroom, a fitting tribute would be to say, “Thank you, Miss Anthrop,” for her lasting legacy and her love of our community.
Continue Mary’s legacy. You can make your own lasting impact on Central Catholic and LCSS students.
- Give today at giving.lcss.org
- Plan a legacy gift by including LCSS in your estate plans and joining the 1850 Society
- Honor a loved one with a Memorial Tree for $10,000
Contact the Advancement Office at 765-474-7500 or giving@lcss.org.


